2016: Brady Bacon
2015: Robert Ballou
2014: Brady Bacon
2013: Bryan Clauson
2012: Bryan Clauson
2011: Levi Jones
2010: Levi Jones
2009: Levi Jones
2008: Jerry Coons Jr.
2007: Levi Jones
2006: John Wise
2005: Levi Jones
2004: Jay Drake
2003: J.J. Yeley
2002: Tracy Hines
2001: J.J. Yeley
2000: Tony Elliott
1999: Dave Darland
1998: Tony Elliott
1997: Brian Tyler
1996: Brian Tyler
1995: Tony Stewart
1994: Doug Kalitta
1993: Robbie Stanley
1992: Robbie Stanley
1991: Robbie Stanley
1990: Steve Butler
1989: Rich Vogler
1988: Steve Butler
1987: Steve Butler
1986: Steve Butler
1985: Rick Hood
1984: Rick Hood
1983: Ken Schrader
1982: Sheldon Kinser
1981: Sheldon Kinser
1980: Rich Vogler
1979: Greg Leffler
1978: Tom Bigelow
1977: Sheldon Kinser
1976: Pancho Carter
1975: Larry Dickson
1974: Pancho Carter
1973: Rollie Beale
1972: Sammy Sessions
1971: Gary Bettenhausen
1970: Larry Dickson
1969: Gary Bettenhausen
1968: Larry Dickson
1967: Greg Weld
1966: Roger McCluskey
1965: Johnny Rutherford
1964: Don Branson
1963: Roger McCluskey
1962: Parnelli Jones
1961: Parnelli Jones
1960: A.J. Foyt (East), Parnelli Jones (Midwest)
1959: Tommy Hinnershitz (East), Don Branson (Midwest)
1958: Johnny Thomson (East), Eddie Sachs (Midwest)
1957: Bill Randall (East), Elmer George (Midwest)
1956: Tommy Hinnershitz (East), Pat O’Connor (Midwest)